Jack

July 20, 2009 under Uncategorized

I’m trying out a little game I thought up. The game is to retell a fairy tale or children’s story while omitting one of the major characters.

This is Jack and the Beanstalk, without the beanstalk (Part 1). Part 2. Part 3.  Part 4.

Jack the Simpleton

A long time ago, there lived a youth named Jack who lived alone with his mother.

They were very poor; indeed they were the poorest in their village, for although Jack was big and strong and worked hard, he was too simple to keep his money. He would be underpaid; he would lose his wages; some trickster would beg for a loan, knowing that Jack would forget about it the next day.

The day finally came when they were entirely out of money, and Jack’s mother told him,
“Jack, we must sell the only thing we have left, our cow. Today you must take her to the market. Be sure that you get a good price for her. Come straight home, and don’t tarry with anyone on the road, or give anyone your money, for this is all we have to buy food with.”

Jack set out with the cow, and had an uneventful trip to the market. He was fortunate to find an honest butcher, who offered him a fair price for the cow. Following his mother’s instructions, he started straight back home. On his way through the woods, however, he turned a sharp corner in the path and found himself surrounded by a group of men who in loud voices bade him halt.

Jack was suprised, for it was well known that the woods were home to a great many bandits. It seemed strange to him that anyone would be in the woods by choice. He was equally surprised that they would express an interest in talking to him. No-one ever showed an interest in talking to him.

So he smiled at them and greeted them warmly.

The men were taken aback. They had expected him to run or to beg for his life… but he seemed completely unafraid.

The leader of the men looked Jack up and down and decided to have some fun with him. With an excess of courtesy, he asked Jack to give him all his money.

Jack looked down. He was embarrassed, and said that although he should like very much to lend them some money, he could not, because his mother had told him he should bring all of it straight home.

There was some sniggering and trading of glances among the men. Jack thought he heard someone at the back mention his mother.

Now I suspect things were about to go very ill for Jack, but, at that very moment, around the corner strode a merchant.

The merchant saw the men and immediately realized what was happening. In a heartbeat he drew his sword and, taking them quite by surprise, charged among them.

Jack’s new friends turned to flee, for they were cowards, and relished no part of a fight with a determined assailant. But when Jack saw this violent attacker rushing upon him and his friends, he knew instantly that they were being attacked by a bandit.

“Leave the ruffian to me!” he bellowed. Springing upon the merchant, Jack dealt him a single tremendous blow that left him senseless on the ground.

The men were impressed.

“Well!” exclaimed the leader. “What a fine fellow! As big and strong as an ox, and it seems that you’re not afraid of anything! We could certainly use someone of your mettle.”

He clapped a friendly hand on Jack’s shoulder, and continued in a kindly voice, “My friends and I guard this forest against evil men… such wicked, despicable men as you might never believe existed. They put on the clothes of proper citizens to hide their villany, but their hearts are black and corrupt. We seek them out where we can, and detain them. We strip them of all their belongings, so as to render them powerless to harm upright people.”

Jack listened, fascinated. It seemed to him that there could be no greater purpose or brotherhood that what was held in this small band. He was drawn by the leader’s kind and generous words.

“If you would consent to join us, I’m sure we could find a place in our band for someone of your strength and courage.”

That was how Jack became a bandit.

comments: 2 » tags: , ,

It’s now official

July 17, 2009 under technical

Facebook breaches Canadian privacy law.

I’ve written about this before, back when it was just a complaint to the Commissioner.

You bet that Facebook’s information about privacy practices is “confusing and incomplete.” Moreover, it’s confusing and incomplete by design, and not merely by accident.

Take a look at this marvellous essay by Bruce Schneier. The golden quote:

“From a business perspective, social networking sites don’t want their members to exercise their privacy rights very much. They want members to be comfortable disclosing a lot of data about themselves.”

There’s a fundamental conflict of interest at work here. The value of a social networking site depends entirely on the degree to which people participate and on the degree to which people post.

If my friends refuse to post embarrassing  photographs of my other friends on Facebook, it is no longer the go-to place for me to look at embarrassing photos of my friends. I’ll have to go elsewhere. Any reluctance to post diminishes the experience. Don’t kill the buzz.

So what makes people nervous about privacy?

Reminding them about privacy. Says Bruce,

Reassuring people about privacy makes them more, not less, concerned.”

Even just mentioning the word makes people perk up and say, “Wow, I still have that? I’d forgotten about that.” So if you want people to throw discretion to the wind, you can’t even talk about privacy. Don’t kill the buzz. Settings become hidden away and convoluted. Education about how to use them takes a backseat.

If you don’t protect your own privacy, who will? Certainly not the business that’s trying to make a buck off of your lack of it.

But… go ahead and post that photo! All press is good press, right?

Right?

comments: 1 » tags: , ,

People, Authentication, and smart computers

July 17, 2009 under technical

At times I’ve been really impressed with the quality of spam messages I’ve seen appearing on blogs. Spam is a hard problem to solve; if it wasn’t, we’d be rid of it by now.

One of the popular defenses against spam is using a captcha. The basic problem that a captcha is trying to solve is, “Are you human?” The way it does it is by trying to present a commenter (could be human or machine) with a problem that a human can solve, but a computer cannot.

The only reason that squiggly lines and letters are used is that humans are relatively good at them and computers are not.

But captchas aren’t perfect, and they’re only going to get less perfect over time. Why? Because they fly in the face of the very problem that computer science is focused on solving:

“How can we get computers to do stuff for us?”

We want computers to be able to do the kinds of things we can do, so that they can do them for us.  (We also want computers to do things we can’t do, but that’s slightly different issue. Actually, anything a computer can do, a human can do, just really, really slowly ; – )

So… at the same time some of us are desperately trying to design great captchas, more of us are desperately trying to design great captcha breakers. Computer scientists around the world are dreaming of a machine as capable as a human, and bloggers around the world are screaming out, “Please, no!”

However, the real problem with a spam message is not that a computer posted it. The real problem is that you don’t want it on your blog, because it’s unhelpful and/or malicious.

The question of “Do I want this?” is a more interesting question to solve. It’s a social question, albeit one in a technical domain. It’s the question that modern e-mail spam filters try and answer, using statistical analysis of word usage to identify stuff you don’t want.

Now… can I think of a computer generated comment that I’d welcome on my blog? The first thing that jumps to mind are related links. If a computer posted a genuine, relevant link (especially if it was a link from a friend’s blog), that might make my post better, not worse, and I’d welcome that. A link to a spammer’s site? Not so much.

But, hypothetically speaking, if a computer could get ‘smart’ enough to post the exact same comment that a friend would have… what’s the difference? The bits are just bits… they don’t care who posted them.

comments: 0 » tags: ,

Stubbies

July 16, 2009 under Uncategorized

It’s a good ad.

comments: 0 »

The cost of being Abmoti

July 15, 2009 under Uncategorized

When last I talked about being A Big Man On The Internet, it was all snark and no substance.

So this time let’s have some stories. The people featured here are not perfectly Abmoti in the petty and infantile way I’ve described him, but they are Big Mans on the Internet. Here are three real world BMI, live and in action.

Guy Kawasaki explains how and why he tweets.

You know you’re Abmoti when you pay four other people to tweet for you. Guy is clinical, but honest. He’s selling himself and his product, and if you don’t like it, you’re free not to buy. Honest, but… kinda soulless.

Commenter ‘Guest’ reacts strongly: “Blech. You’re all disgusting excuses for people.

Guy’s blog is titled, “How to change the world” but he never actually says in what direction. I think if you asked him, he’d probably say “It’s up to you to supply the vision, I just tell you how you can bring it about.”

Are all visions compatible with an arbitrary method of bringing them about?

Dave Winer talks about the Twitter SUL.

It really makes Dave angry that someone at Twitter can suggest, “Follow so-and-so” and bump them by several thousand followers. Sure it’s not fair and it’s not right, but… Dave really seems absorbed in his world of The People Are The Press And My Followers Are Me.

If you mess with followers, it seems you strike right at the heart of what’s important to Dave. And so arbitrarily giving someone front page coverage is a personal insult to him, because he’s competing, and you’ve just skewed the playing field.

To the point that his #1 suggestion is that Twitter actually cut someone’s followers.

Dave is living in the world of a Big Man’s number game. Followers to him are a score; they are framed in terms of a Big Man. It’s more important for a Big Man’s numbers to add up, so according to Dave it’s okay to reverse the decisions of 700,000 people.

Jeff Atwood  does battle with a long time detractor.  Commenter Pablo summarizes (1st link):

“If you’re a nobody… how do you get attention?

Simple, just go against everything that a well-known person says even if they are completely right, there you go! you got your 15 minutes at last!” [For the record, I don't think Dennis Forbes is necessarily wrong. He's not a nobody either, he has the same 'person' status as Jeff and Pablo]

When fame is the game, you have to spend a lot of time and effort to gain it. Just like everything else. That’s the cost of being Abmoti.

It’s worse with fame though, because Dennis Forbes can post on Jeff Atwood’s blog, and his 200 characters there are exactly as large as Jeff Atwood’s 200 characters. And every time Dennis is right and Jeff is wrong, it’s a reminder of how small the difference between them really is. And then you’re tempted to follow Dennis Forbes’s blog.

At least in Hollywood stars have a media industry to shore them up. On the internet it’s entirely up to them.

comments: 0 » tags: , , , , ,

Blast from the past

July 14, 2009 under curios

The Anguish Languish and I go way back, especially Ladle Rat Rotting Hut.

Douglas Crockford‘s site is worth checking out, too. Especially if you like Javascript.

comments: 0 » tags: ,

Boots – Part III

July 13, 2009 under Uncategorized

I’m trying out a little game I thought up. The game is to retell a fairy tale or children’s story while omitting one of the major characters.

This is Puss in Boots, minus the kitty (Part 3). Part 1. Part 2.

Come back next Monday for Jack and the Beanstalk (w/out the Beanstalk) part 1.

It was the Princess’s weekly visit to the Marquis de Carabas, but she was unhappy.

“The problem,” sighed the Princess, “is my father.”
She was quiet for a moment.
“And my mother.”
“And the court.”

The Marquis looked up from the pair of summer sandals he was fitting on her.

“They might say that the problem is *me*” he said dryly. “Or perhaps you.”

The Marquis stood up; he looked as his feet. “As dashing and impressive as my boots are,” he said, “I don’t think your father or your mother or the court will ever accept a cobbler as the suitor of a princess. Even such a cobbler as the Marquis of Carabas. I can shoe you, but not suit you. I can bear a sole, but can never bare a soul. I…”

“Shush,” said the Princess. “This is serious. I can’t keep on buying shoes like this. My father’s getting wise. Besides, all the neighboring princes are starting to get impatient. I can’t keep stringing them along forever.”

What she said was true. The King *had* been noticing the Princess’s sudden interest in shoe shopping. “She can’t possibly wear all those shoes,” he had grumbled, and the Princess hadn’t known what to say, because she really *couldn’t* wear all those shoes.
She wasn’t buying shoes, she was buying time with the Marquis, and it was rapidly coming time to settle the tab.

“If nothing changes,” said the Princess, “I’ll have to stop coming. I’ll have to marry one of the princes.”

“The Marquis de Carabas can’t be a cobbler.” said the Marquis de Carabas. He looked down at his boots once more. “It’s a shame. I liked these shoes.”

But the Marquis de Carabas made one last trip in his favorite boots, and it was to an ogre’s castle. The ogre lived on the edge of the kingdom. He held a castle with much land, and had plagued the King for years. He had annexed the King’s land, eaten his people, slain his knights. Though everyone hated him, no one could do anything about him.

The ogre was surprised by the arrival of the Marquis, for he solicited no vistors. In fact, he usually ate visitors. He was ten feet tall, and near as wide, but as soon as he opened his castle gate, the Marquis swept him away by sheer force of personality.

“I’m here to see you, my dear.” cried the Marquis, “on a matter of the utmost importance.”

The Marquis blew right past the ogre, up to the Great Hall of the castle, and straight to the ogre’s chair. He draped himself across it, putting his boots up on the Ogre’s table, brushing the bones of the ogre’s supper away with his heels.

“The court, my dear, is so dull!” he exclaimed. “There’s no challenge, no invention. These courtiers all want the same things, and so awful! A lady yesterday asked me for rhinestones! Rhinestones!”

The Marquis flitted off the chair and came close to the ogre, lowering his voice and adopting a tone of secrecy.

“I’d tell you who it was, but you wouldn’t believe it. Horrible! Simply ghastly. But you, my dear… Such lovely large feet that walk oh so far off the beaten path. What challenge, what interest! To my eyes, the most beautiful feet in the world.”

The ogre looked down. He could scarce see his feet for his belly, making out only the the corner of a huge toe. The ogre’s feet were hard as iron and matted all over with coarse, thick black hair.

“I need no shoes” rumbled the ogre.

The Marquis sidled closer to the ogre. “If half the rumours I hear in the court are true,” he said slyly, “Those aren’t the only feet you have.”

In the flash of the eye the ogre disappeared; in his place stood a huge tiger, roaring and snarling. The Marquis was utterly terrified.

“M-M-Marvelous, my dear,” he stuttered. “Boots for claws and paws! What a delightful challenge.”

Suddenly the ogre was back, towering over him.

“You like it?” he smirked.

The Marquis was struggling to reclaim his breath and his nerves. “I love it, it’s fabulous.” he said. “But my specialty, my dear, my claim to fame, is my attention to detail, my meticulous and perfect work at things too small for the human eye to appreciate. Have you not,” here he paused and dropped his voice to near a whisper, “have you not a *tiny* set of feet against which I can test my skill?”

In the flash of an eye, the ogre disappeared, and in his place stood the tiniest of white mice.

The Marquis wasted no time, for seeing the ogre thus transformed was his sole purpose in coming. He killed the mouse with a single blow of his heel.

When the King received an invitation to a ball, signed “The Marquis de Carabas”, he felt it must be some sort of joke.
“The cobbler?” he cried. “A craftsman seeks to entertain a King?”
He was about to burn the card when the Queen quietly pointed out that the ball was being held at the Ogre’s castle.

“You might want to see what it’s about.” she said. The truth was, she didn’t care about the Ogre, but she was sure of one thing. If the Marquis de Carabas was holding a ball, she was not going to miss it. Cobbler or not, a place on the Marquis’s schedule was not a thing to be gambled with.

So it was that the King, the Queen, and the whole court made their way to the Ogre’s castle. Oh, and the Princess came as well, though to her ladies in waiting she appeared flushed, agitated and quite unfit to travel.

Driving through the countryside, the King could not resist stopping the carriage at every possible opportunity to interrogate the road-side serfs. It infuriated the Queen to no end, but the King would have his way.

“To whom does this cornfield belong?” he would demand.
“To whom does this mill belong?”
“To whom does this forest belong?”

“The Marquis de Carabas,” was the invariable reply.

“A cobbler owns half my country, and I have yet to hear of it!” cried the King. The truth was, all the land he had lost to the Ogre had been lost by force, and he was frightened of meeting anyone powerful enough to slay him.

When the guests arrived at the castle, they were escorted with great courtesy to the banquet hall, where places had been laid for one and all. The hall was thick with the tantalizing aroma of exotic meats and sauces, but thicker still was the feeling of anticipation and anxiety.

What manner of host had brought them here?

The guests had scarce taken their seats when a trumpet sounded, and they all, King, Queen, Princess and court, lept out of them again. The Marquis de Carabas was entering the hall.

Aftwerwards, as they gathered for the dance, every noble poured forth praise of the Marquis – the authority of his presence, his nobility, his grace. They marvelled at the eloquence of his welcoming speech. They extolled his courtesy.

They rhapsodized at the splendour of the castle. The lords mouthed amazement over the lavish feast he had provided. The ladies swooned at the cut of the crystal.

“No cobbler, he.” was the unanimous verdict. Indeed, the dastardly cobbler was dismissed in an instant. Such a wretch he was, to claim the name of such a nobleman as the Marquis de Carabas! “I’ll never visit him again!” was the indignant cry of every noblewoman. (And then, quieter, “But I simply can’t waste the perfectly good pair I already have from him.”) Truthfully, the appearance of the *real* Marquis proved such a blow to the reputation of the cobbler that he must have fled the country, for after that night he was never heard from again.

There was only one person in the hall who said nothing about either the nobleman *or* the cobbler.
She’d looked at his face, and not at his feet.

It was sometime the next morning, and the party was close to wrapping up, when the Princess stumbled upon the King and the Marquis, having a conversation in one of the smoking rooms. The King’s arm was draped over the Marquis’s shoulders.

“Seriously, m’lord,” he was slurring, “she only cares about her blasted shoes. She won’t look twice at any of the princes. I can’t blame her. Halfwits and ne’er-do-wells all! But a man of character, now…”

The King’s voice trailed off. The Marquis de Carabas laid him down on the sofa.

“He doesn’t half snore, does he?” shouted the Marquis.
The Princess grinned. “You’d better get used to it.” she yelled. “It’s hereditary!”

comments: 2 » tags: ,

Wondermark 533

July 12, 2009 under curios

Comedy gold.

comments: 0 » tags:

He’s not crazy…

July 10, 2009 under curios

He’s just saying something different than you.

comments: 1 » tags: , ,

Feeling superior

July 9, 2009 under Uncategorized

This is the part of the blog where I call something stupid to make myself feel superior.

But in this case, I feel thoroughly justified, mostly because in my self admittedly not so humble opinion, it is stupid, and I am superior. ;-)

In short, I just saw a television advertisement for breakfast cereal where a giant chicken runs around dumping fruit in peoples’ cereal.

“Surprise yourself. Mix it up.” is what they’re saying.

I wish it wasn’t true. No, wait, I wish it was true. I wish a giant chicken did appear with fresh strawberries for my cereal. But I wish it wasn’t true that I just saw an advertisement which straight up admitted, “Our product is soooo boring that you’ll find yourself wishing a guy in a chicken suit would show up. With strawberries. So that you can enjoy eating the strawberries. They may even make our product tolerable.”

Look, I’m willing to accept the picture on the box, the one with splashing milk and strawberries. That’s okay. That’s expected. It even has tiny letters that would read, “Serving Suggestion” if I could make them out. Everyone knows the picture on the box is supposed to look good and subliminally influence you to buy it. Even if you know there aren’t any strawberries in the box. And that’s okay.

But Big Cereal Company:  don’t tell me that! Don’t tell me that in order to enjoy your food, I am required to go buy some other really exciting, enjoyable food. I don’t get it. Why would you ever do that?

9 out of 10 people love our sawdust when it’s served with caviar. Um… yay sawdust?

I never like to think of someone as stupid, but in this case… I’m just returning a favor. :-P

comments: 0 » tags: ,